I pay for my sins, big time, at the cashier.
If that's the case, then, yes, he paid for his sins.
Well, he was going to pay for his sins now.
He made people pay for their sins no matter what they did.
"It's highly probable we will have to pay for our sins after life on earth."
You must pay for her sins, just as the others do.
I never should have tried to make you pay for your father's sins.
"So how do people pay for their sins, in that religion?"
And she had made the two traitors pay for their sins against her family.
Now, she thought with some pity, he was paying for his sins.
Idiomy